California vs. French Wine: The Real Story Behind Round One |
Fifty years after the Judgment of Paris, a California victory still makes a compelling story—with an important distinction between history and cartoon entertainment. |
The bell rings. Two wine bottles enter the ring. California lands the winning punch. Our Wine Cork Weekly animation gives wine history a playful boxing treatment, but the result behind round one comes from a real tasting.
On May 24, 1976, wine merchant Steven Spurrier and his colleague Patricia Gallagher organized the event now known as the Judgment of Paris. Nine French experts judged wines served blind, comparing California Cabernet Sauvignons with prestigious Bordeaux reds, alongside a separate comparison of California Chardonnays and French white Burgundies. Each category included six California wines and four French wines.
The red-wine winner was Stag’s Leap Wine Cellars’ 1973 Cabernet Sauvignon from Napa Valley, identified by the winery as its S.L.V. Estate Cabernet Sauvignon. Château Mouton-Rothschild 1970, from Bordeaux, finished second. The California wine also placed ahead of other celebrated French competitors, including Château Haut-Brion and Château Montrose.
That makes these particular bottles a strong choice for our opening cartoon matchup. However, the original competition involved ten reds—not an actual two-bottle boxing contest. The knockout is our fictional way of presenting the winning result.
The tasting’s significance extended beyond a single trophy. California’s first-place finishes challenged assumptions about where exceptional wine could be made and helped bring international recognition to its producers. In the white category, Chateau Montelena’s 1973 Chardonnay also took first place. In 2026, the Smithsonian recognized the tasting’s 50th anniversary, underscoring its lasting place in American wine history.
Still, one historic result does not establish that California wines always outperform French wines. Different vintages, bottles, tasting conditions, and judging panels can produce different outcomes.
France has victories worth celebrating, too. At the 2024 Judgement of London, the top-scoring red was France’s 2012 Jean-Louis Chave Hermitage, followed by 2009 Château Mouton-Rothschild. That broader international event illustrates why our series should follow documented results rather than favor a country.
For round one, California earns the celebration. For wine lovers, the larger invitation is to explore both sides with curiosity.
The judges made their choices. Now it’s your turn—which wine would you choose? |

0 Comments
Join the conversation
Be the first to comment
Share your thoughts above.